Editor(s):

(1) Dr.  Shaharior Rahman Razu, Khulna University, Bangladesh.

Reviewers:

(1) Safi Ullah, QURTUBA University, Pakistan.

(2) Marge Ethan U. Odoya, North Eastern Mindanao State University, Philippines.

Additional Reviewers:

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.25/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Safi Ullah, Pakistan) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Marge Ethan U. Odoya, Philippines) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Prof . M. Camino Escolar-Llamazares , University of Burgos, Spain.

Reviewers:

(1) Yesi Arikarani, Sekolah Tinggi Agama Islam (STAI), Indonesia.

(2) Fareeha Javed, Govt. Graduate College for Women Gulberg, Pakistan.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Azwar Rahmat, Sekolah Tinggi Ilmu Ekonomi Syariah Nahdlatul Ulama Bengkulu, Indonesia.

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.5/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Yesi Arikarani, Indonesia) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Fareeha Javed, Pakistan) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Hayder Ali Mohammed Al-Keraway, University of Kerbala, Iraq.

Reviewers:

(1) Mehmet Ramazan Risvanli, Van Yuzuncu Yil University, Türkiye.

(2) Chander Singh, Dr. Yashwant Singh Parmar University of Horticulture and Forestry, India.

(3) Fatima Lizeth Gandarilla Pacheco, Instituto De Biotecnología, Universidad Autonoma De Nuevo Leon, Mexico.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Md Ali Azgar, Uttar Banga Krishi Viswavidyalaya, India.

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 6.83/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Mehmet Ramazan Risvanli, Türkiye) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Chander Singh, India) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_3 (Fatima Lizeth Gandarilla Pacheco, Mexico) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Hayder Ali Mohammed Al-Keraway, University of Kerbala, Iraq.

Reviewers:

(1) Praveen Kumar, Agriculture University Jodhpur, India.

(2) Draghici Elena Maria, University of Agronomic Sciences and Veterinary Medicine of Bucharest, Romania.

(3) Manpriya, Canada.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Hawraa Yahya Mohammed, Al-Furat Al-Awsat Technical University, Iraq.

(2) Nadeem Qayoom Dar, Kurukshetra University, India.

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 6.83/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Praveen Kumar, India) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Draghici Elena Maria, Romania) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_3 (Manpriya, Canada) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Meryem ALTUN EKİZ, Hatay Mustafa Kemal University, Turkey.

Reviewers:

(1) Emmanuel Dumbuya, Njala University, Sierra Leone.

(2) Maryam Chinasa Adewunmi, University of Johannesburg, South Africa.

(3) Muhammad Rafiq-uz-Zaman, The Islamia University of Bahawalpur, Pakistan.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) B.R.Kumar, Andhra Loyola College, India.

(2) Majid Abdulmohammed Jassim, Iraq.

(3) Pooria Barzan, Ilam University, Iran.

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 7.33/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Emmanuel Dumbuya, Sierra Leone) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Maryam Chinasa Adewunmi, South Africa) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_3 (Muhammad Rafiq-uz-Zaman, Pakistan) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr.  Shaharior Rahman Razu, Khulna University, Bangladesh.

Reviewers:

(1) K Rajakumari, Bharath Institute of Higher Education and Research (BIHER), India.

(2) Matthew Damilola Omojemite, Walter Sisulu University, South Africa.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Bety Hetharion, University of Pattimura, Indonesia.

(2) Ezema Jideofor Marcus, Nigeria.

(3) James. I Wojuade, Emmanuel Alayande University of Education, Nigeria.

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.25/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (K Rajakumari, India) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Matthew Damilola Omojemite, South Africa) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Sérgio Thode Filho, Federal Institute of Education, Science, and Technology, Brazil.

Reviewers:

(1) Susintowati, Indonesia.

(2) Ateeqa Baloch, University of Karachi, Pakistan.

Additional Reviewers:

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 7.9/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Susintowati, Indonesia) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Ateeqa Baloch, Pakistan) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Fang Xiang, University of International and Business Economics, China.

Reviewers:

(1) Shyam Shukla, Bangalore University (NSB Bangalore), India.

(2) Aqsa Iram Shahzadi, Bahauddin Zakariya University Multan, Pakistan.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Laxhmi Narayan Das, Utkal University, India.

(2) Manoj Kumar B R, Xavier Institute of Management and Entrepreneurship, India.

(3) Neena Brar, Shaheed Bhai Mani Singh Khalsa College, India.

(4) Shyam Shukla, Bangalore University (NSB Bangalore), India.

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 7.9/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Shyam Shukla, India) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Aqsa Iram Shahzadi, Pakistan) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Giuseppe Murdaca, University of Genoa, Italy.

Reviewers:

(1) Nistor Cristina Coralia, University of Medicine and Pharmacy Carol Davila, Romania.

(2) Tejosmita Chowdary Pavuluri, The State University of New Jersey, USA.

Additional Reviewers:

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.25/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (Nistor Cristina Coralia, Romania) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Tejosmita Chowdary Pavuluri, USA) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Editor(s):

(1) Dr. Jichao Sun  , China University of Geosciences, Beijing, China.

(2) Dr. Neha Munjal, Lovely Professional University, India.

(3) Dr.  Shu-Lung Kuo, Open University of Kaohsiung, Kaohsiung City, Taiwan.

Reviewers:

(1) K. Sindhura, MEASI Institute of Management, India.

(2) Enekwe, Chinedu Innocent, ANAN University Kwall, Nigeria.

(3) Agustina Dian Putri Manurung, Satu Padu Boarding School, Indonesia.

(4) Shallu Sehgal, Shoolini Institute of Life Sciences and Business Management, India.

Additional Reviewers:

(1) Abdul Rahman, Muhammadiyah University of Palu, Indonesia.

(2) Bassey Ibor, University of Calabar, Nigeria.

(3) Faisaluddin, Universitas Bhamada Slawi, Indonesia.

(4) Ferdinandus Sampe, Atma Jaya Makassar University, Indonesia.

(5) Ratnaningrum, Indonesia.

Open Peer Review Policy: Click Here

Specific Comment:

Average Peer review marks at initial stage: 8.32/10

Average Peer review marks at publication stage: 9/10

Peer Review History:

Stage 1 | Original Manuscript | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_1 (K. Sindhura, India) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_2 (Enekwe, Chinedu Innocent, Nigeria) | File 1 | File 2

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_3 (Agustina Dian Putri Manurung, Indonesia) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Peer Review Report_4 (Shallu Sehgal, India) | File 1 | NA

Stage 2 | Revised_MS_v1_and_Feedback_v1 | File 1 | File 2

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_1_v1 | File 1 | NA

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_2_v1 | File 1 | NA

Stage 3 | Comment_Editor_3_v1 | File 1 | NA